| WEB TV
VERSION |
Arguments
Against Water Fluoridation from the National Academy of
Sciences |
The
following quoted material is taken from the Institute of Medicine's
On-Line DIETARY REFERENCE INTAKES at www.nap.edu/books/0309063507/html/288.html Simple answers are provided for the following
questions: |
|
|
|
"Fluoride is the ionic form of fluorine, a halogen and the
most electronegative of the elements of the periodic table. It is
ubiquitous in nature."

|
|
"80
percent or more is typically absorbed. ... The elimination of
absorbed fluoride occurs almost exclusively via the kidneys. ... For
healthy, young, or middle-aged adults, approximately 50 percent of
absorbed fluoride is retained by uptake in calcified tissues, and 50
percent is excreted in the urine. For young children, as much as 80
percent can be retained owing to increased uptake by the developing
skeleton and teeth. Such data are not available for persons in the
later years of life. ... Under most dietary conditions, fluoride
balance is positive. Whether it is positive or negative appears to
be due to the blood-bone fluoride steady state. When chronic intake
is insufficient to maintain or gradually increase plasma
concentrations, fluoride excretion by infants and adults can exceed
the amounts ingested due to mobilization from calcified
tissues."

|
|
"The
cariostatic action of fluoride on erupted teeth of children and
adults is due to its effects on the metabolism of bacteria in dental
plaque and on the dynamics of enamel de- and remineralization during
an acidogenic challenge. Plaque fluoride concentrations are directly
related to the fluoride concentrations in and frequencies of
exposure to water, beverages, foods, and dental products. Fluoride
can be deposited in plaque by direct uptake from these sources as
well as from the saliva and gingival crevicular fluid after
ingestion and absorption from the gastrointestinal tract. Its
effects on plaque bacteria involve inhibition of several enzymes,
which limits the uptake of glucose and thus reduces the amount of
acid produced and secreted into the extracellular plaque fluid.
These effects attenuate the pH drop in plaque fluid that would
otherwise occur and, hence, the severity of the acidic challenge to
the enamel."
- If
the fluoride from all these sources works just as well in
preventing cavities, and works in exactly the same way ... and
fluoride is "ubiquitous," then why should it be added to drinking
water?

|
|
"In a
study of fluoride intake by 225 children aged 2 to 10 years, Pang et
al. (1992) reported that total fluid intake ranged from 970 to 1,240
ml/day. Consumption of soft drinks, juices, tea, and other beverages
accounted for more than 50 percent of fluid intake and ranged from
585 to 756 mg/day. The fluoride concentrations ranged from
nondetectable to 6.7 mg/liter."
- NAS/NRC has commented more than once that during the years
prior to 1945, water was virtually the only source of ingested
fluoride. The typical U.S. diet provided about one quarter
milligram of fluoride daily.
- Not long ago a petition appeared in the Federal Register
for an increase in the allowances for fluoride in pesticide
residues on fruits and vegetables. According to this document,
"EPA has estimated previously that levels of fluoride in/on food
from the agricultural use of cryolite plus fluoride levels in U.S.
drinking water supplies results in a daily dietary intake of
fluoride of approximately 0.095 mg/kg/day." Federal Register:
August 7, 1997
- According to McClure, the only reference cited in
Dietary Reference Intakes, adults ingested 0.02
mg/kg/day in an "optimally fluoridated area" during the 1940s. For
a 70 kilogram man (154 pounds) that's 1.4 mg/day. Now, it appears
to be 6.65 mg/day ... far more than the original "optimum" daily
intake for maximum benefits and minimum risk.
- In
1993 NAS/NRC commented on evidence that excess fluoride may be
responsible for increased dental decay in some areas. More
recently, the head of preventive dentistry at the University of
Toronto, Dr. Hardy Limeback, a former pro-fluoridationist, said
that in his practice, and among his colleagues, cosmetic dentistry
is taking more time than dental decay ... and more
money.
- For a discussion of the Surgeon General's role in promoting
fluoridation, see The Cover-up at the
U.S.E.P.A. in Applying the NAEP Code of Ethics to the
Environmental Protection Agency and the Fluoride in Drinking Water
Standard, written by EPA scientist
witnesses.

|
|
"Both
the inter-community transport of foods and beverages and the use of
fluoridated dental products have blurred the historical difference
in the prevalence of dental caries between communities with and
without water fluoridation. ... The overall difference in caries
prevalence between fluoridated and nonfluoridated regions in the
United States was 18 percent ..."
- At
the same time, according to NAS/NRC, the milder forms of dental
fluorosis are common in both fluoridated and non fluoridated
communities ... in one city mentioned by NAS/NRC in 1993, the rate
was reported to be eight times higher than was reported in
1942.

|
|
According to (Dean 1942) ... "reduction in the number of
dental caries per child was nearly maximal in communities having
water fluoride concentrations close to 1.0 mg/liter. This is how 1.0
mg/liter became the 'optimal' concentration."

|
|
"Although the total amount of fluoride ingested daily by
older children and adults is greater than by infants or young
children, it is generally lower when expressed in terms of body
weight. As noted earlier, average dietary fluoride intakes by adults
living in fluoridated communities have ranged from 1.4 to 3.4
mg/day, or from 0.02 to 0.05 mg/kg/day for a 70 kg person."
- During the 1940s, according to the only reference cited
here, it was 0.05 mg/kg/day for children age 1-3 ... 0.04
mg/kg/day for children aged 4-9 ... 0.03 mg/kg/day for children
aged 10-12 ... and 0.02 mg/kg/day for
adults.
The 1.4 figure above refers to the dosage
delivered in optimally fluoridated areas during the 1940s. The
other figure refers to a study published in 1974.
- The DRI uses the figure 0.05 mg/kg/day, which applies to
fluoride intake at age 1-3 in 1943. However, only a portion of
McClure's data is shown in the DRI table ... leaving out the
intake figures for older children and adults. The incorrect use of
the 0.05 mg/kg/day figure has resulted in an incorrect 3 to 4
mg/day "adequate intake" for everyone age 19 and over. This error
is the foundation for the DRI's new "AI" for
fluoride.
Ironically, according to the only reference
they cite regarding the tolerable upper limit for safety, even
smaller daily doses of fluoride – 0.04 mg/kg/day – could result in
phase 3 skeletal fluorosis after 55 to 96 years. (Roholm: 0.2
to 0.35 mg/kg/day resulted in phase 3 crippling skeletal fluorosis
after 11 years ... NAS/NRC 1977: "a retention of 2 mg/day would
mean that an average individual would experience skeletal
fluorosis after 40 yr")

|
|
"The
primary adverse effects associated with chronic, excess fluoride
intake are enamel and skeletal fluorosis."

|
|
"Stage 1 skeletal fluorosis is characterized by occasional
stiffness or pain in joints and some osteosclerosis of the pelvis
and vertebra."
"The
clinical signs of stages 2 and 3, which may be crippling, may
include dose-related calcification of ligaments, osteosclerosis,
exostoses, possibly osteoporosis of long bones, muscle wasting, and
neurological defects due to hypercalcification of vertebra."
"The
development of skeletal fluorosis and its severity is directly
related to the level and duration of exposure."
|
|
"Crippling skeletal fluorosis continues to be extremely rare
in the United States (only 5 cases have been confirmed during the
last 35 years), even though for many generations there have been
communities with drinking water fluoride concentrations in excess of
those that have resulted in the condition in other countries. This
puzzling geographic distribution has usually been attributed to
unidentified metabolic or dietary factors that rendered the skeleton
more or less susceptible."
- No
studies on the long-term arthritic effects of fluoride have been
published in which the researchers used appropriate methods, but
failed to find evidence of harm. Please read the symptoms of phase
1, 2, and 3 skeletal fluorosis above. Are there more than 5 cases?
Not being fatal or contagious, skeletal fluorosis is not a
"reportable" disease. That does not mean it does not exist in the
United States.
|
|
"Studies are needed to define the effects of metabolic and
environmental variables on the absorption, excretion, retention, and
biological effects of fluoride."
- Do
we have the right to refuse to participate in medical experiments?
Does the government have the right to use our children in medical
experiments?
- If
so, how do we avoid fluoride in foods, beverages, etc.?
- Keep in mind that when the Dietary Reference Intakes was
released during a press conference in the early fall of 1997, a
representative of the American Dental Association read the segment
on fluoride, as though he wrote it himself. The man in charge of
determining the tolerable upper limit of fluoride is a
representative of the American Council on Science and Health ... a
tax-exempt group which receives most of its funding from Monsanto
and other similar interests. Fluoridation saves billions of
dollars for industries with fluoride pollution problems.
- If
one were to correct the errors in arithmetic in Dietary
Reference Intakes, the material quoted above would not
only fail to support a proposal to add more fluoride to our
children's or our own diet – it would show clearly that
fluoridation can no longer be considered "safe" or
"effective."

|
| Total Daily Fluoride Intake
During the 1940s - McClure |
Age (years)
|
Body weight (kg) |
From
drinking water (mg) |
From
food (mg) |
Total (mg) |
Average (mg/kg/day) |
13 46 79 1012 |
816 1324 1635 2554 |
0.3900.560 0.5200.745 0.6500.930 0.8101.165
|
0.0270.265 0.0360.360 0.0450.450 0.0560.560
|
0.4170.825 0.5561.105 0.6951.380 0.8661.725
|
0.05 0.04 0.04 0.03
|
| 19+ |
61-76 |
0.800-1.200 |
0.200-0.300 |
1.0-1.5 |
0.02 |

|
| DRI's version of McClure vs. McClure,
1940s |
| age |
weight/lbs |
weight/kg |
0.05 mg/day |
McClure |
| 1-3 |
28.66 |
13 |
0.65 |
0.65 |
| 4-8 |
48.50 |
22 |
1.1 |
0.88 |
| 9-13 |
88.18 |
40 |
2 |
1.2 |
| 14-18 |
125.662 |
57 |
2.85 |
1.14 |
| 14-18 |
141.09 |
64 |
3.2 |
1.28 |
| 19-70 |
134.48 |
61 |
3.05 |
1.22 |
| 19-70 |
167.55 |
76 |
3.8 |
1.52 | |

|
Minimum Fluoride Intake Which
Causes Crippling Skeletal Fluorosis Among Healthy
Individuals according to NAS/NRC
references |
| author
| grand total
| based on |
| Roholm
| 36,525 mg
| 0.2 mg/kg/day for 11 years (100 lbs) |
| Hodge 1979
| 36,525 mg
| 10 mg/day for 10 years |
| NAS/NRC 1993
| 36,525 mg
| 10 mg/day for 10 years |
| 100 lb person
| 36,525 mg
| 2.5 mg/day for 40 years
|
| 134 lb woman
| 48,944 mg
| 3.35 mg/day for 40 years
|
| 168 lb man
| 61,362 mg
| 4.2 mg/day for 40 years |
"Existing
data indicate that subsets of the population may be unusually susceptible
to the toxic effects of fluoride and its compounds. These populations
include the elderly, people with deficiencies of calcium, magnesium,
and/or vitamin C, and people with cardiovascular and kidney problems. ...
Because fluoride is excreted through the kidney, people with renal
insufficiency would have impaired renal clearance of fluoride ... Impaired
renal clearance of fluoride has also been found in people with diabetes
mellitus and cardiac insufficiency. People over the age of 50 often have
decreased renal fluoride clearance. ... This decreased clearance of
fluoride may indicate that elderly people are more susceptible to fluoride
toxicity. ... Because of the role of calcium in bone formation, calcium
deficiency would be expected to increase susceptibility to effects of
fluoride." Toxicological Profile for Fluorides, Hydrogen Fluoride, and
Fluorine (F), (April 1993), U.S. Dept. Health and Human Services,
Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, p.112

|
| Daily Fluoride Intake Associated With Phase III
Skeletal Fluorosis |
body weight pounds |
|
| 229 |
| 220 |
| 210 |
| 200 |
| 190 |
| 180 |
| 170 |
| 160 |
| 150 |
| 140 |
| 130 |
| 120 |
| 110 |
| 100 | |
minimun mg/day 11 years |
|
| 20.7747 |
| 19.9582 |
| 19.0510 |
| 18.1438 |
| 17.2366 |
| 16.3294 |
| 15.4222 |
| 14.5151 |
| 13.6079 |
| 12.7007 |
| 11.7935 |
| 10.8863 |
| 9.9791 |
| 9.0719 | |
maximum mg/day 11 years |
|
| 36.3558 |
| 34.9269 |
| 33.3393 |
| 31.7517 |
| 30.1642 |
| 28.5766 |
| 26.9890 |
| 25.4014 |
| 23.8138 |
| 22.2262 |
| 20.6386 |
| 19.0510 |
| 17.4634 |
| 15.8758 | |
minimum mg/day 44 years |
|
| 5.1936 |
| 4.9895 |
| 4.7627 |
| 4.5359 |
| 4.3091 |
| 4.0823 |
| 3.8555 |
| 3.6287 |
| 3.4019 |
| 3.1751 |
| 2.9483 |
| 2.7215 |
| 2.4947 |
| 2.2679 | |
maximum mg/day 44 years |
|
| 9.0889 |
| 8.7317 |
| 8.3348 |
| 7.9379 |
| 7.5410 |
| 7.1441 |
| 6.7472 |
| 6.3503 |
| 5.9534 |
| 5.5565 |
| 5.1596 |
| 4.7627 |
| 4.3658 |
| 3.9689 | |
| Drinking Water and Health, Safe Drinking Water Committee,
National Academy of Sciences, NAS/NRC, 1977 p.
371-372 |
| Harold C. Hodge, Ph.D., The Safety of Fluoride Tablets or
Drops, Continuing Evaluation of the Use of Fluorides, AAAS
Symposium, Boulder, CO, Westview Press, 1979, p.254.
|
| Health Effects of Ingested Fluoride, Committee on
Toxicology, Board on Environmental Studies and Toxicology,
Commission on Life Sciences, National Research Council, August 1993,
p.59 |
Roholm, Kaj, Fluorine Intoxication: A Clinical-Hygienic
Study With a Review of the Literature and Some Experimental
Investigations, Translated. by W.E. Calvert., London: H.K. Lewis
& Co., Ltd., 1937. 0.2 to 0.35 mg/kg/day for 11 years - data
base for Hodge, NAS/NRC | |
|
References
... recommended reading
- Fluoridation Facts, American Dental Association.
- Recommended Dietary Allowances, National Research Council,
1980, 1989.
- The Safety of Fluoride Tablets or Drops, Harold C. Hodge,
Continuing Evaluation of the Use of Fluorides, AAAS Symposium, Boulder,
CO, Westview Press, 1979.
- Ingestion of fluoride and dental caries – quantitative relations
based on food and water requirements of children 1 to 12 years old,
Frank J. McClure, American Journal Diseases of Children, 66:362,
1943.
- Report of the Ad Hoc Committee on the Fluoridation of Water
Supplies, Division of Medical Sciences, National Research Council,
Nov. 29, 1951.
- The problem of providing optimum fluoride intake for prevention
of dental caries, Food and Nutrition Board, Division of Biology and
Agriculture, National Academy of Sciences, National Research Council,
Pub. #294, November 1953
- Health Effects of Ingested Fluoride, Subcommittee on Health
Effects of Ingested Fluoride, Committee on Toxicology, Board on
Environmental Studies and Toxicology, Commission on Life Sciences,
National Research Council, August 1993.
- Biologic Effects of Atmospheric Pollutants FLUORIDES,
Committee on Biologic Effects of Atmospheric Pollutants, Division of
Medical Sciences, National Research Council, National Academy of
Sciences, Washington, D.C., 1971 p 214
- Drinking Water and Health, National Research Council,
1977
- Fluorides and Human Health, World Health Organization, 1970,
pp 32, 239-240.
- Non Dental Physiological Effects of Trace Quantities of
Fluorine, Frank J. McClure, Journal American College of Dentists -
12:50, (1945).
- Fluoridation of Water, Special report by Bette Hileman,
Chemical & Engineering News -August 1, 1988 p 35-36
- Dietary Fluoride In Different Areas in the United States,
Kramer, Osis, Wiatrowski & Spencer, American Journal of Clinical
Nutrition - 27:590-594, 1974
- Toxicological Profile for Fluorides, Hydrogen Fluoride, and
Fluorine (F), (April 1993), U.S. Dept. Health and Human Services,
Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, p.112
- Endemic Dental Fluorosis or Mottled Enamel, Dean, H.
Trendley, Journal American Dental Association, 30:1278, 1943
- The Fluoride Content of Some Foods and Beverages, Journal of
Food Science 31:941, 1966
- Review of Fluoride Benefits and Risks, U.S. Department of
Health and Human Services, 1991
|